Pilgrim Hat Cookies, Thanksgiving Feast
November 16, 2012 by Aimee • 16 Comments
Pilgrim Hat Cookies are so easy and are welcomed with a huge smile, because they are pure cuteness and because anyone who sees these realized that this is a dessert that they could throw together without much stress! For Halloween, I made cookies and packaged them individually for Big B’s classmates. I think his teacher caught on that I love making cookies and in Big B’s folder this week was a request for 24 cookies for Big B’s Thanksgiving Class Feast. Pilgrim Hat Cookies was the obvious choice! This is such an easy craft and involves absolutely no cooking and very little time!
Here are the ingredients you’ll need for Pilgrim Hat Cookies!
Just four – store bought ingredients! Yellow Icing, Orange Tic Tacs, Peanut Butter Cups, and Striped Fudge Cookies.
Layer your cookies like this…a striped fudge cookie (stripes down), 1 teaspoon of frosting around the hole on the cookie (squeeze from the tube), peanut butter cups (unwrapped and upside down) on top of the frosting, and an orange tic tac to finish off the look with the appearance of a buckle!
Pilgrim Hat Cookies Keep Thanksgiving full of smiles! Happy Thanksgiving Week…for more Creative Thanksgiving Recipes.


















These are super cute, Aimee! I’m pinning this.
I am adding this to my dessert list for Thanksgiving
ADORABLE.
Completely clever and cute! Pinned it! Happy Thanksgiving!
Great idea. These are cute and perfect for Thanksgiving!
Alison
These are too cute! Visiting from the Sundae Scoop!
Featuring today or tomorrow on Bacon Time! Happy Thanksgiving
These are so cute & they look delicious! I’m stopping by from Stone Gable blog hop.
Thanks
Angie
I am soooooo making these!
Thank you!
Happy Thanksgiving!
~Liz
You had me at “peanut butter cup.”
Cute and delicious.
I’m sure the pilgrims would be proud. And confused!!!!
Love them! I was hoping you’d be bringing them to our Thanksgiving Feast
So glad they were enjoyed by your sweet kiddos and their friends.
Hugs,
Nici
Those are sooo cute. And they look yummy too!
These are darling! My kids would love them – and they would love making them, which is saying something! I’d love for you to share this at Tuesday’s Table for the Holidays – http://zentmrs.blogspot.com/2012/11/tuesdays-table-holiday-ideas.html
I’m going to do this with the kids tomorrow! They will absolutely love this!
Very cute…love the idea!
Yumm!! These look delicious!! Thanks for sharing! I am a new follower after finding you through a linky party. I hope that you will stop by my site if you get a chance. http://www.thetaylor-house.com
Adorable! What a fun idea for kids!